Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Signature Cake Collection
Order your favorite cakes online and pick up at our store! Please place your order at least 7 days in advance.
Soft Love Collection
A collection of cakes designed to celebrate love in every form. Soft textures, delicate finishes, and timeless flavors — perfect for meaningful moments and sweet celebrations.
Velvet Love
A classic red velvet cake paired with three layers of velvety cream cheese frosting. Light, balanced, and elegantly finished — designed for a refined Mother’s Day celebration.
$55.00
Sweetheart Cake
A charming three-layer cake finished with smooth buttercream, a hand-piped red heart, and soft gold accents- simple, sweet, and made to celebrate love. Available in any cake flavor!!
$60.00
Permanent Line
The "Special Request" box is ONLY for buttercream writings you want on the cake. No other changes can be made to pre-designed cakes.
Semi-Naked
Simply white frosted cake in "semi-naked" style. Great to add your own cake topper or flowers to match any theme. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$65.00
Horizontal Line
Simple white frosted cake with line texture. Great for adding cake toppers and flowers to match your theme! 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$65.00
Rustic Gold Edge
Lightly textured, white frosted cake with a hand-painted gold edge to create a modern rustic look. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$75.00
Brush Strokes
Rustic yet elegant texture with a touch of gold flakes. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling in the flavor of your choice.
$85.00
Ombre Line Texture
Simple and elegant ombre design perfect to add your own cake topper of flowers to match any theme! 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$85.00
Concrete
Simplicity with an edge! Perfect to add your own cake topper of flowers to match any theme! 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$85.00
Boho
Stylish wave and buttercream piping. Elegant by itself or with a cake topper. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling in the flavor of your choice.
$95.00
Dream A Little Dream
Stylish wave and buttercream piping. Elegant by itself or with a cake topper. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling in the flavor of your choice.
$95.00
Mini Cake Sample Box
Taste some of our flavors before ordering for your event or just feel like having cake! Choose any 5 flavors of your choice: Simply Vanilla, Funfetti, Belgian Chocolate, Cookie&Cream, Lemon Raspberry, Sweet Marble, Simply Lemon, Strawberry Vanilla, Chocolate Raspberry, Red Velvet, Pistachio, Carrot.
$25.00
Vintage Piping Cakes
Retro cake designs perfect for fun & chic parties. The "Special Request" box is ONLY for buttercream writings you want on the cake. No other changes can be made to pre-designed cakes.
Black Bow Vintage
Simple black and white Victorian style perfect for any chic party! 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$95.00
Simply White Heart
Simple and timeless heart-shaped cake. 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling of your choice.
$100.00
Pastel Heart
Customize with your favorite pastel color! Approximately 8" in diameter. Serving 12-14
$125.00
Pastel Round
Simple and timeless.
$75.00
Monotone Heart
Customize with your favorite pastel color! Simple and timeless heart-shaped cake. 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling of your choice.
$110.00
Spring Fling
This dainty vintage cake design will give every party a breath of spring and its hostess something to be proud of!
$95.00
Tea Party
This dainty vintage cake design will give every party a breath of spring and its hostess something to be proud of!
$95.00
Blushing Belle
A timeless beauty with delicate buttercream piping and hand-piped florals in soft blush and pastel tones. Perfect for garden parties, showers, and sweet celebrations with a touch of vintage charm.
$110.00
Caketail
Inspired by your favorite drinks, these fun-packed mini heart shaped cakes would sure to make any day special!
Espresso Martini
Approximately 4" in diameter Serve 1-2
$75.00
Classic Martini
Approximately 4" in diameter Serve 1-2
$75.00
Pink Champagne
Approximately 4" in diameter Serve 1-2
$75.00
Themed Cakes
Fun & cute popular themed cakes fit for birthdays, showers and other occasions. The "Special Request" box is ONLY for buttercream writings you want on the cake. No other changes can be made to pre-designed cakes.
The Astronaut
Fun and chic edible print design for an out-of-this-world party! 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling of your choice.
$115.00
Donut Shop
Sweet and fun bakery themed cake. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling in the flavor of your choice.
$115.00
Ice Cream Truck
Sweet and fun ice cream truck themed cake. 4 layers of cake and 3 layers of filling in the flavor of your choice.
$115.00
Sheet Cakes
Sheet cakes make it easy to portion and serve at any parties. Our sheet cakes are elegantly decorated and work great with cake toppers. Write in "Special Request" the message you want to write on your cake!
Victoria
Classic shell piping 1/4 sheet cake. Available in 2 sizes: 3 layers of cake: serving 35-37 4 layers of cake: serving 45-50
$170.00
Rosy
Rosette piping 1/4 sheet cake. Available in 2 sizes: 3 layers of cake: serving 35-37 4 layers of cake: serving 45-50
$180.00
Jenny
Funky piping 1/4 sheet cake. Available in 2 sizes: 3 layers of cake: serving 35-37 4 layers of cake: serving 45-50
$170.00
Flavor Spotlight (Top Customer Picks)
Our most popular flavors, selected based on customer demand and updated regularly.
Pistachio Velvet
Moist pistachio sponge layered with silky cream cheese filling, finished with fresh pistachios and smooth buttercream.
$65.00
Velvet Love
A classic red velvet cake paired with three layers of velvety cream cheese frosting. Light, balanced, and elegantly finished — designed for a refined Mother’s Day celebration.
$55.00
Sweet Treats & Dessert Boxes
Order your favorite Simply Sweet treats online is never easier!
Bars
Perfect bites of deliciousness sure to entertain your guests at any parties! All bars are bite-size, approximately 1.5"x1.5" and sold by 30 pieces
Pecan Pie Bars
Toffee, caramel and toasted pecans on a shortbread crust. Mini bars measured approximately 1.25" x 1.25". Sell by 30 pieces.
$48.00
Lemon Bars
Sweet and tangy lemon curd on a shortbread crust.Mini bars measured approximately 1.25" x 1.25". Sell by 30 pieces.
$48.00
Strawberry Crumbles Bars
Strawberry jam and oatmeal crumbles on a shortbread crust. Mini bars measured approximately 1.25" x 1.25". Sell by 30 pieces.
$48.00
Brookies
Chocolate chip cookie baked on top of a rich layer of brownie. Mini bars measured approximately 1.25" x 1.25". Sell by 30 pieces.
$48.00
Brownie
Rich decadent chocolate fudge brownie. Mini bars measured approximately 1.25" x 1.25". Sell by 30 pieces.
$48.00
Petite Party Cookies
Bite-sized, buttery, and full of flavor — our mini cookies are perfect for sharing, gifting, or treating yourself to a little something sweet. Each batch is 30 pieces
$38.00
Mini Butter Croissants
Flaky, buttery, and perfectly bite-sized — our mini croissants are handmade with real butter and baked fresh daily for the ultimate little indulgence. 15 pieces per batch
$30.00
Mini Chocolate Dipped Croissants
Flaky, buttery, and chocolatey — our mini croissants are hand-dipped in dark chocolate for the ultimate little indulgence, 15 pieces per batch
$38.00
Cupcake Collection
Cupcakes are always in season! They are great to serve, no cutting needed and no one can resist the cuteness. Simply Sweet Cakery's ready-to-order selection of cupcakes is simple and elegant and works well with any theme
Standard Cupcakes
Standard cupcakes are filled with delicious filling before decorated with vanilla buttercream frosting.
Simple Swirl
A dozen of cupcakes with a classic swirl of vanilla French buttercream frosting. Great with sprinkles or any topper!
$45.00
Two-tone Rosettes
A dozen of cupcakes with two-tone piping of vanilla French buttercream frosting.
$55.00
Mini Cupcakes
Bite-size cupcakes are frosted with vanilla buttercream or cream cheese buttercream.
Mini Swirl
A dozen of bite size cupcakes with a classic swirl of French vanilla buttercream. Perfect with sprinkles
$28.00
Color Swirl
A dozen of bite size cupcakes with a classic swirl of French vanilla buttercream. Perfect with sprinkles
$32.00
